UNCANNY MAPSomething happened hereOpen on the map

The Cahow's Return

CreaturesCastle Harbour, Bermuda · 28 January 1951Confirmed

A seabird thought extinct for nearly 300 years was found nesting on rocky islets off Bermuda.

What was reported

Early visitors to Bermuda knew a seabird, the cahow, whose eerie night cries are said to have given the islands a reputation as the 'Isle of Devils'. Settlers, and the pigs and rats they brought, ate the birds, and by the 1620s they were thought to be extinct.

On 28 January 1951, an expedition led by the ornithologist Robert Cushman Murphy and Louis Mowbray found cahows nesting in crevices on small islets in Castle Harbour. A 15-year-old local boy on the trip, David Wingate, went on to devote his life to saving them.

Explanations offered

The Bermuda petrel is real, and still endangered. Only a handful of pairs survived. Decades of conservation, including artificial burrows and moving chicks to safer Nonsuch Island, have brought the population back to well over 100 breeding pairs.

When
28 January 1951
Where
Castle Harbour, Bermuda
Witnesses
Robert Cushman Murphy, Louis Mowbray and the teenage David Wingate
Status
Confirmed

Famous cases are real, widely reported events. Each file sets out what witnesses said and the explanations that have been offered, without taking a side.